REVIEW: Merrell Pace Glove shoes

Adventuretess' favorite paddling shoes are falling apart.
After serving her very well for 3 years on her frequent paddling trips the sole has started to come apart from the upper. Time for new ones.
While the Merrell Waterpro were a very good choice since they offer excellent support and a very sturdy sole (to protect the foot from sharp rocks and the occasional broken bottle) the upper part of the shoes had a lot of padding that took a long time to dry.
It was time to look at alternatives. Away from water sports, the emerging craze of barefoot running is taking the USA by storm, with Vibram Fivefingers being the leading brand. The low profile design appeared to suit the snug fit required in low volume kayaks.
Fivefingers offer minimal support and are very low profile however they only fit feet that are "square" in shape where the second toe is longer than the big toe. Fivefingers don't fit a lot of people.
Merrell has followed the new trend of barefoot running with a slightly beefier shoe that has more of traditional look but lacks the hefty padding in the sole.
This spring (Northern hemisphere) they released the Pace Glove.

Initially designed for running off-pavement the shoe has almost no cushioning and minimal fabric in the upper making an ideal candidate for a paddling shoe.
Since all its materials are synthetic the Pace Glove has no problem getting wet.
The sole is a Vibram offering (the absolute best grip and durability in the biz) has low profile lugs that offer outstanding traction on slippery boat ramps. The heel has a gentle curve that allows a comfortable rest of the foot when seated in the cockpit (no Achilles tendon dig-in either).

The shoe is very low profile and contours the foot's shape with no "empty" pockets. It does therefore fit well in low volume cockpits. It is rather flexible to allow some feel from the foot rest pegs but the sole is stiff enough to prevent sore feet after an energetic long paddle with positive legs drive in one's stroke.

The only problem are the shoe laces. Obviously takes more time to lace up shoes than just pull a toggle to secure them on the feet. The Merrel Waterpro had the toggle. Shoe laces also have to be tucked away to prevent possible entanglement with the cockpit foot pegs or other protruding fittings.
Obviously these shoes offer no insulation and probably not suitable for cold water paddling. They are however an ideal compromise of support, safety and durability for our style of paddling.

GEAR: paddling shoes review.

Sea kayaking takes me to paddling locations where good footwear is essential equipment.
While the climate I paddle in does not require insulated footwear I only occasionally frequent beaches where footwear is not necessary.
I need protection for my feet.

The kayaks I paddle have small footpegs that don't offer a platform large enough to push off with bare feet.
My heels also need cushioning when paddling.
Since I started kayaking a few years back I have always worn some kind of footwear in the boat.

My first choice was the obvious inexpensive "water shoe" that is sold at many chandleries and discount stores. It seems to be popular for snorkeling.

The shoe was cheap but did not suit my paddling needs.
It quickly became evident that a shoe with a soft sole, absence of a proper heel, inferior fabric and lack of decent foot retention would only last me so long.
I lost those shoes a few times in the surf when I wet exited.
My heel was getting rubbed and fortunately I had to move on.
My second choice was only marginally better then my first.

While the quality seemed better and the Velcro strap would keep those shoes on my feet, the heel was even worse than the first shoes.

The heel area is square and not stiff enough to prevent it from collapsing when resting on an angle inside the cockpit.

this soft heel would collapse when feet are in the cockpit of the kayak

After a month of cursing them I decide it was time to actually get a shoe that offered support and was suited to walk on a beach with sharp coral or cone shells.

I purchased the Merrel Waterpro shoes.

Adventuretess wearing her Merrell Waterpro

Finally there was a sole that I could trust on the sharp rocks and oysters.

A shoe with a Vibram sole that would not see me skating at the boat ramp (siping of the sole makes them stick even to wet surfaces).

This shoe has a decent lace-up to conform to most foot shapes and stays put when walking in the shore waves.

They dry fast and don't stink like neoprene booties do.

They do however collect sand inside the shoe, that occasionally does not drain that well.

Sitting in the kayak cockpit and wiggling my feet overboard usually dislodges the annoying sand...

The men's version of the Waterpro lasted me just over a year and then the sole started to separate from the upper.

A new pair proved to have the same problem after just two months, starting at the ball of the foot.

A bit of contact glue repair keeps them going for a while longer.

delaminating fabric coating repaired with contact glue

I then purchased a lower volume kayak where my size 11.5 (US) Waterpro would not fit that well under the deck.

I needed a low volume bootie.

Searching for a sole stiffer than a scuba-diving-bootie I found the Teva white-water boat shoes.

They had all the right reinforcements, low profile, good volume (for my slender feet) and traction.

the stitching used to have black rubber strips...

While not exactly easy to put on (some serious wiggling was necessary) the shoe would fit in low decked kayaks.

After half an hour of paddling I noticed that the fabric big toe divider inside the shoe was annoying and rubbing.

Some really tricky cutting inside the shoe eventually removed the web.

The shoes however started to fall apart.

The cosmetic rubber strip placed over the stitching (no longer visible in the attached image) ripped off in several places.

After a few outings there were rubber strips dangling over the shoe... I cut them off.

This shoe proved not to be all that comfortable.

Adventuretess wore out her Merrel Waterpro and purchased some Chaco water shoes.

The fit, finish and sturdiness of these shoes is impressive.

Adventuretess sporting Chacos

Chaco's reputation for long lasting sandals seems to cross over to their shoes.

However these shoes have a bit of padding in the fabric that absorbs water and takes longer to dry than other light shoes. Not a real problem in 90F heat but a bit annoying in the middle of winter.

Vanilla (maker of Vanstix) has a wider foot and he prefers the Teva Sunkosi.

Onto his second pair, he finds them very comfortable and perfectly suited for paddling, or those short hikes up a mountain in the Whitsundays.

Vanilla's Teva

After some searching I came across these Merrells.

Not marketed as water but as running shoes the design is minimalistic.

There is no padding in the fabric and plenty of ventilation.

The sole is very close fitting to the shape of the shoe (no "air" or "gel" here) and the heel is stiff enough to be supportive.

The Merrell Robotic are low volume, small enough to fit under low deck kayaks.

They don't slip on wet concrete and have plenty of traction for an exploratory hike.

The fabric is light but reinforced with "rubber dots" to prevent premature wear.

Unfortunately they are only a few months old and I can't report yet on the durability of these.

I am sure that some readers might be laughing at me with this "obsession" for good footwear just for kayaking but after witnessing a few cone shells pierce a light bootie and injuring the kayaker's foot I am glad that I seek firmer footwear.

Foot injury on long remote trips could spell disaster.

On the other hand I have observed people paddling in thongs (the Australian type, a.k.a as flip-flops on the other side of the pond) or Crocs... puzzles me how they keep them on their feet when landing on wavy shores.